12/11/2012

Are record fines the new normal?

HSBC was fined for money laundering activities tied to drug cartels in Mexico and terror-linked groups in Saudi Arabia in December 2012. .HSBC was fined for money laundering activities tied to drug cartels in Mexico and terror-linked groups in Saudi Arabia in December 2012. .
Standard Chartered was levied the fine on August and December 2012 for violating U.S. sanctions on transactions with Iran, Burma, Libya and Sudan.Standard Chartered was levied the fine on August and December 2012 for violating U.S. sanctions on transactions with Iran, Burma, Libya and Sudan.
In June 2012. ING Group was charged for covering up fund transfers in violation of U.S. sanctions against Cuba and Iran.In June 2012. ING Group was charged for covering up fund transfers in violation of U.S. sanctions against Cuba and Iran.
Swiss banking giant Credit Suisse was penalized for allowing clients in Iran, Libya, Sudan, Myanmar and Cuba to conduct financial transactions.Swiss banking giant Credit Suisse was penalized for allowing clients in Iran, Libya, Sudan, Myanmar and Cuba to conduct financial transactions.
Barclays Banking Group faced the fine for rigging the Californian electricity market in November 2012.Barclays Banking Group faced the fine for rigging the Californian electricity market in November 2012.
The group was charged for manipulating bank Libor rates in June 2012.The group was charged for manipulating bank Libor rates in June 2012.
Allowing Iranian and Sudanese clients access to the U.S. banking system cost Lloyds TSB Group the hefty sum in January 2009.Allowing Iranian and Sudanese clients access to the U.S. banking system cost Lloyds TSB Group the hefty sum in January 2009.
Bank of America was fined in February 2012 for charging discriminatory lending rates to African American and Latino borrowers.Bank of America was fined in February 2012 for charging discriminatory lending rates to African American and Latino borrowers.
Barclays was fined earlier in August 2010 for allowing client payments from Cuba and Sudan.Barclays was fined earlier in August 2010 for allowing client payments from Cuba and Sudan.
In February 2012, JPMorgan Chase was levied for problems in its mortgage servicing business.In February 2012, JPMorgan Chase was levied for problems in its mortgage servicing business.
The Royal Bank of Scotland was forced to pay the amount in June 2012 for manipulating bank Libor rates.The Royal Bank of Scotland was forced to pay the amount in June 2012 for manipulating bank Libor rates.
 Ally Financial, based at the Renaissance Center in Detroit, Michigan, was also charged in February 2012 for problems in mortgage servicing business. Ally Financial, based at the Renaissance Center in Detroit, Michigan, was also charged in February 2012 for problems in mortgage servicing business.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
  • HSBC to pay record $1.92 billion to U.S. authorities to settle money laundering accusations
  • "We accept responsibility for our past mistakes," says HSBC Group CEO Stuart Gulliver
  • Standard Chartered agreed to pay $327 million to settle U.S. Treasury Department charges
  • At least 21 global banks have paid millions in fines since 2009 for a variety of charges

(CNN) -- In a historic fine, HSBC will pay out a record $1.92 billion to U.S. authorities to settle money laundering accusations -- activities which have allegedly occurred with drug cartels in Mexico and terror-linked groups in Saudi Arabia. U.S. authorities declared HSBC, the UK's biggest bank by market capitalization, in breach of a series of U.S. laws, including the Trading with the Enemy Act.

"We accept responsibility for our past mistakes. We have said we are profoundly sorry for them, and we do so again. The HSBC of today is a fundamentally different organization from the one that made those mistakes," HSBC Group CEO Stuart Gulliver, said in a statement.

On Monday, Standard Chartered, the UK's second largest bank by market value, agreed to pay $327 million to settle U.S. Treasury Department charges of violating sanctions on transactions with Iran, Burma, Libya and Sudan between 2001 and 2007. In August Standard Chartered paid $340 million to the state of New York's Department of Financial Services to settle civil charges alleging it had concealed $250 billion in illegal transactions with Iran.

But while this week's fines are record fees, they are not earth-shattering when compared to the billions of dollars the banks boast in market values, assets and profits.

According to Quartz, it will take HSBC a mere 41 days to earn back the $1.9 billion fine.

"These banks are big and you can argue that these kinds of settlements have some mitigating effect on risk-taking," says Gary Biddle, professor of accounting at the University of Hong Kong. But "HSBC has about a $123 billion market cap today so its ($1.9 billion) fine is about 1%. This is not a huge amount. The stock price will vary that much in any given day anyway."

Indeed, HSBC's share price appears to have not suffered in light of these charges. In Hong Kong trading, HSBC Holdings rose 0.31% by mid-day Tuesday. Since news of HSBC's allegations hit in mid-July, HSBC's share price in Hong Kong has risen 16.3%. In the same time period in London trading, its share price has risen nearly 15%.

Since the start of 2009, there have been at least 21 instances where global banks and financial institutions have been fined -- predominantly by U.S. authorities. Cases include a $536 million fine against Credit Suisse in December 2009 for allowing clients in Iran, Libya and Cuba to conduct financial transactions; a $335 million fine against Bank of America on racial discrimination charges in lending rates; and a $619 million fine against ING Bank NV that involved a cover-up of fund transfers that violated U.S. sanctions against Cuba and Iran.

Biddle says bank improprieties will continue as long as governments continue to back them -- fallout from the 2008 financial crisis when the U.S. labeled some banks: "Too big to fail."

"The obvious natural consequence of governments bailing out banks, or any industry for that matter," says Biddle, "is that executives are able to take on more risk (and) governments bailing out banks puts us all at risk."

The Dirty Dozen: Biggest fines of the banking world since 2009

1. $1.9 billion, HSBC, December 2012. Charge: Accused of money laundering activities tied to drug cartels in Mexico, terror-linked groups in Saudi Arabia.

2. $667 million, Standard Chartered, August and December 2012. Charge: Violating U.S. sanctions on transactions with Iran, Burma, Libya and Sudan.

3. $619 million, ING Bank NV, June 2012. Charge: Covering up fund transfers in violation of U.S. sanctions against Cuba, Iran.

4. $536 million, Credit Suisse, December 2009. Charge: Allowing clients in Iran, Libya, Sudan, Myanmar and Cuba to conduct financial transactions.

5. $470 million, Barclays, November 2012. Charge: Rigging electricity market.

6. $450 million, Barclays, June 2012. Charge: Manipulating bank Libor rates.

7. $350 million, Lloyds TSB Group. Charge: Allowing Iranian and Sudanese clients access to the U.S. banking system.

8. $335 million, Bank of America, December 2011. Charge: Racial discrimination in lending rates.

9. $298 million, Barclays, August 2010. Charge: Allowing client payments from Cuba, Sudan.

10. $275 million, JPMorgan Chase, February 2012. Charge: Problems in mortgage servicing business.

11. $233 million, Royal Bank of Scotland, June 2012. Charge: Manipulating bank Libor rates.

12. $207 million, Ally Financial, February 2012. Charge: Problems in mortgage servicing business.

No comments:

Post a Comment