10/02/2012

Ferry survivors recount chaos, horror

  • 37 people drowned after ferries collide of Hong Kong's Lamma island
  • Survivors recall chaos, speed the passenger vessel sank in the water
  • One of the boats had been ferrying passengers to a fireworks display
  • Impact was like hitting a rock or a lighthouse, another passenger says

Hong Kong (CNN) -- What started off as an exciting boat trip to celebrate China's National Day in Hong Kong, quickly turned into a nightmare for more than 100 passengers on board.

Local power company, Hong Kong Electric, had been ferrying a group of its employees and their families to watch an evening fireworks display in the city's Victoria Harbor when it collided with a ferry heading from Hong Kong Island to Lamma -- one of 200 outlying islands in the territory.

Within minutes, passengers on board the stricken vessel described how quickly the water rushed in.

"First it was up to here, and then here. The water rose so quickly. We thought we were going to die for sure," one woman, who declined to be named, told CNN affiliate, i-Cable.

Read more: Hong Kong's worst ferry disaster in decades

Dozens dead in ferry accident
Celebration turns tragic in Hong Kong
The bow of a boat that collided with a Hong Kong passenger ferry is partially submerged during rescue operations Tuesday, October 2. At least 38 people died in the accident that happened Monday, October 1, near Lamma Island. Authorities are still looking for missing passengers.The bow of a boat that collided with a Hong Kong passenger ferry is partially submerged during rescue operations Tuesday, October 2. At least 38 people died in the accident that happened Monday, October 1, near Lamma Island. Authorities are still looking for missing passengers.
 A woman cries Tuesday as she leaves a public mortuary holding the bodies of those who died in the boat collision. A woman cries Tuesday as she leaves a public mortuary holding the bodies of those who died in the boat collision.
The vessel that collided with the passenger ferry off Hong Kong's Lamma island is pulled from the water.The vessel that collided with the passenger ferry off Hong Kong's Lamma island is pulled from the water.
The vessel was reportedly taking passengers to watch the city's Chinese National Day fireworks display.The vessel was reportedly taking passengers to watch the city's Chinese National Day fireworks display.
Rescuers approach the sinking vessel late Monday. Rescuers approach the sinking vessel late Monday.
A survivor is helped onto an ambulance. The crash necessitated what local police called a "major rescue" operation, according to China's state-run media.A survivor is helped onto an ambulance. The crash necessitated what local police called a "major rescue" operation, according to China's state-run media.
Local residents try to get a glimpse of rescue personnel as they tend to a victim Monday night. The incident happened around 8:20 p.m. local time, just off the coast of Lamma Island, southwest of Hong Kong.Local residents try to get a glimpse of rescue personnel as they tend to a victim Monday night. The incident happened around 8:20 p.m. local time, just off the coast of Lamma Island, southwest of Hong Kong.
Rescuers search for survivors near the crash site. More than 100 people were picked up.Rescuers search for survivors near the crash site. More than 100 people were picked up.
Survivors are transported to shore on a police boat late Monday.Survivors are transported to shore on a police boat late Monday.
Medical and rescue personnel wait for survivors by the ferry pier.Medical and rescue personnel wait for survivors by the ferry pier.
A victim is carried ashore Monday.A victim is carried ashore Monday.
Rescuers approach an overturned boat. A local company had rented one of the boats for a staff holiday outing.Rescuers approach an overturned boat. A local company had rented one of the boats for a staff holiday outing.
A rescuer looks through a window of the rapidly sinking ship.A rescuer looks through a window of the rapidly sinking ship.
A passenger is helped on shore. Survivors were taken to a number of public hospitals.A passenger is helped on shore. Survivors were taken to a number of public hospitals.
Members of the media surround rescue workers as they carry a victim into an ambulance Monday night.Members of the media surround rescue workers as they carry a victim into an ambulance Monday night.
The crash sent dozens of passengers into the water. The crash sent dozens of passengers into the water.
Rescue crews search for passengers in the waters off Lamma Island. It's unclear how many people remain unaccounted for, authorities say.Rescue crews search for passengers in the waters off Lamma Island. It's unclear how many people remain unaccounted for, authorities say.
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
Photos: Deadly Hong Kong ferry crashPhotos: Deadly Hong Kong ferry crash

"Everyone was underwater. The boat overturned, everything came crashing down, the chair slid down."

Another woman recounted her terrifying ordeal trying to free herself from her seat as the boat sank.

"My leg was stuck and I couldn't get it out. I thought I wouldn't be able to get it out and I was going to die," she said.

"The water was suffocating me. My friend tugged with all her might and got my leg out. I was wearing a life jacket so I floated up to the surface. I had swallowed a lot of water. I really thought I was going to die. Thinking about all those at the bottom who were stuck, they're not here anymore."

A male passenger described the chaos as the boat rolled violently.

"I opened the window and pushed a child out. I put a life jacket on him and pushed him out first," he told i-Cable. "At the time it was very chaotic. The boat was completely standing straight up in the water. It was chaotic. All the tables and chairs were everywhere. It was like a slide, everything was sliding down."

But the shocked survivor admitted he didn't know where his wife was.

Rescue services, quickly on the scene with boats and helicopters, managed to pluck more than 100 people from the water, though 28 were declared dead on the scene, while another 9 died in hospital.

The boat was completely standing straight up in the water. It was chaotic.
Survivor

The other vessel involved -- a regular passenger ferry -- managed to limp to the safety of the pier just a few hundred meters away on Lamma, located southwest of Hong Kong Island.

Witnesses on board the ferry described the moment the two vessels collided.

"We suddenly heard a loud noise. Then the boat swung to one side and we lost our balance," one man, named as Mr. Yip, told i-Cable. "People fell, they fell off their seats, they hit themselves. After a while when everything calmed down, we saw we were almost at the pier, so we asked the captain if we could dock first.

"When we did so, our boat was flooded -- the front of the ship had water in it, so people got nervous again."

Chris Head, a teacher from Lamma, said the ferry went from what felt like full speed to "an abrupt halt." He told CNN he thought they'd hit "a rock or a lighthouse."

Meanwhile, rescuers continued their search for survivors off Lamma on Tuesday morning in full view of commuters, as ferries resumed their services to the main islands to the north.

Were you there? Share your stories, images and videos.

CNN's Jane Sit contributed to this report.

Social media hones cynical edge in presidential politics

In the first presidential campaign since social media came of age, the campaigns of President Barack Obama and Mitt Romney are both struggling to learn the new rules of the road.

By Bob Sullivan

When you're watching the first presidential debate Wednesday night, don't believe what you see. Online, that is. As Mitt Romney and Barack Obama make their inevitable slip-ups and fact-challenged assertions, bring your well-trained skepticism to every computer, cell phone and tablet screen near you.

Jokes that seem to catch fire on their own -- remember Clint Eastwood's invisible Obama from the Republican convention? -- might not be quite so organic. Twitter themes that seem to be everywhere might not be popular so much as purchased. And stinging one-liners that show up in your streams and news feeds might make you chuckle, but they are probably half-truths, and most definitely not a great tool for picking the leader of the Free World.

Even if you aren't on Twitter, virtually all political reporters are, and they increasingly take their cues from it. This is the first presidential election in which social media will play a mainstream role, and it's important to remember not everything is as it seems online.


Four years ago, Facebook and Twitter had only just begun to capture the world's imagination (Pew says that 10 percent of the electorate used social media in 2008 to research candidates, and Twitter was scarcely 2 years old on election night). But with this election cycle, the social media giants are now key outlets for candidates to transmit their messages to voters. While social media may appear to offer unfettered, uncontrollable discussion of candidates and their positions, the campaigns are hard at work learning how to manipulate the tools to their advantage. And there's added spice to the Internet element of this season's presidential campaign -- because social media is so new, rules of engagement are lacking.

For example, Barack Obama famously held a surprise virtual town hall on Aug. 29, offering to take questions from Reddit.com users, embracing that site's standard "Ask Me Anything" (AMA) format. The event was unusual because it occurred during the height of the Republican National Convention, breaking the well-established convention that candidates don't upstage each other during their opponent's convention. Obama almost certainly wouldn't have held a traditional press conference that day -- but a Reddit AMA?  Who's to say that was a violation of unwritten politicking rules? When suspicion arose that questions from the AMA might have been less spontaneous than they first appeared, many observers chimed in with cynical reminders that real-world town halls and press conferences also include plants. Who's to say what rules should apply on Reddit?

About the same time, Romney's campaign made what is believed to be the first major campaign purchase of a "sponsored hashtag," attempting to corral discussion on Twitter around the topic "#AreYouBetterOff?" Simultaneously, a parody Twitter account named MexicanMitt was temporarily suspended. A month or two earlier, Romney's number of Twitter followers shot up by a surprising amount. Are such hashtag purchases tasteful? Was suspension of the account coincidental? Is it fair to purchase followers? Again, the online rules aren't clear. 

There is little argument that Obama's campaign, which held an exclusive on grass-roots Internet campaigning last time around, holds a major advantage over Romney on Twitter and Facebook. Some of that is pure demographics -- new Web tools skew younger and more liberal. But some of it is the result of well-timed sarcasm campaigns. Each time Romney trips over his tongue, you can be sure a cascade of social media comedy  -- a "meme," in Internet lingo -- will follow. Sometimes, that's an organic outpouring of creativity. Sometimes, that's the work of an Obama supporter like Matt Ortega. He told Salon earlier this year that he was behind a website named "EtchASketchMittRomney.com," which appeared almost immediately after top Romney aide embarrassingly said that the candidate's campaign positions in the GOP primary could be easily changed, as if they were written on an Etch-A-Sketch. Ortega said he owns dozens of other similarly sarcastic websites, all powered by the pickup they get on Twitter and Facebook. Ortega is a Democratic consultant, but swears the sites are unpaid hobby work.

Turning candidates into punch lines
There's certainly nothing wrong with being funny. Obama's Reddit chat didn't break any rules; neither did Romney's Twitter advertising. But is social media a free-for-all? Perhaps, said Brad Phillips, a media consultant who runs MrMediaTraining.com. But he's not convinced that social media has made things worse. Campaigns have always stretched the rules -- and the truth -- to get any advantage possible, he said.

"Think about the Willie Horton ads (pillorying Michael Dukakis in 1988). So many others," Phillips said. "If the Internet existed in those campaigns, would they have used online tactics? Of course." Nor would campaign managers from elections past have fretted about scheduling a virtual press conference during an opponent's convention, he said. In some ways, he's surprised there hasn't been much evidence presented yet of "dirty tricks" online, such as the whisper campaign during the 2000 primaries alleging that John McCain had an illegitimate child.

On the other hand, Twitter and Facebook have created one huge new avenue for attack, Phillips said -- the power of humor. Once upon a time, the biggest threat to a candidate could be a misstep so bad that it became fodder for late-night TV humor on Johnny Carson's "Tonight Show."

While that's still true -- an unplanned appearance on David Letterman's Top 10 List can really hurt -- Twitter and Facebook allow campaigns to create their own late night butt-of-joke moments without needing a comedy writer to see it their way. It's easy to argue that the real damage from Clint Eastwood's halting Republican Convention speech came from the hours of sarcastic Tweets and Facebook discussions that began before Eastwood even finished speaking.

"In the past, you knew a crisis had jumped the firewall when it appeared on late night TV as a joke....that meant the issue had gone beyond being just a story for political types," Phillips said. "You wonder if same dynamic is played out now online. If you can make a candidate a punch line (in social media) you've scored a hit."

Phillips also said sarcastic memes could slowly but surely wear down a candidate's chances, cumulatively building and impression that "a candidate is a joke," which would be hard to counteract.

"Is that clean (campaigning)?" he asked. "I don't know. But in future political cycles, I believe candidates will have to pay a lot more attention to this."

Clean or not, University of Virginia professor and presidential politics expert Larry Sabato has been sharply critical of both campaigns -- and political reporters -- for getting caught up in what he calls the "Gaffe Game." Hunting for the next one-liner is a poor way to evaluate presidential candidates, he says.

"When we tire of Gaffe Game, let's have a POTUS Spelling Bee. Would be about as revealing," he said recently in his own Twitter feed.

Scoring points through sarcasm is hardly new, but Sabato believes social media has indeed accelerated the gaffe obsession in this election cycle.

"Many people are on (Twitter) for hours every day. Do they make it worse? Is the pope German? They drain every gaffe of every ounce of meaning and political advantage," he said. "Every time a candidate has a blunder or tongue-twister, Twitter explodes with commentary defending and deriding the candidate."

On the other hand, there is hope, Sabato thinks. Social media seems to accelerate the news cycle, too, meaning that gaffes come and go quicker than they would in the past.

"They … destroy the gaffe quickly -- it burns itself out on Twitter faster than it would otherwise," he said.

Campaign zingers now 140 characters?
So does social media help or hurt the election process? Naturally, it's impossible to say. But it's important to note that voters shouldn't be fooled by what might seem like more personal connections offered by candidates through Facebook "Likes," "personal" e-mails and Tweets. In Phillips' impression, candidates are far more sterilized and prepackaged than ever.

"The candidates are so carefully controlled, access to them is controlled, they are trying to prevent any kind of YouTube moment. (Candidates' moves) are planned within an inch of their lives," he lamented. It's hard to believe that only five presidents ago, reporter Sam Donaldson and President Ronald Reagan sparred during fairly spontaneous press conferences. And vice presidential candidate Geraldine Ferraro spent two hours answering reporters' questions about her tax returns.

Today's candidates usually hide behind carefully orchestrated digital personas, lobbing one-liners over the wall in an attempt to slowly move the needle on the small number of undecided voters who will swing the election.

"Candidates are giving away the ability to have a knockout fantastic answer," he said. "They are just trying to advance in inches not in yards," he said.

That raises the discouraging possibility that the key to who wins and who loses on Nov. 6 could be which candidate comes up with the best joke that fits in 140 characters or fewer.

* Follow Bob Sullivan on Facebook.
* Follow Bob Sullivan on Twitter.

 More from Red Tape Chronicles:

 

Welsh residents hunt missing girl

Police released this photo of April Jones, who went missing on Monday evening.
Police released this photo of April Jones, who went missing on Monday evening.
  • Five-year-old girl abducted while she played on street near her home in Wales
  • Hundreds of people spent night scouring land around mid-Wales town of Machynlleth
  • Dyfed-Powys Police say they are "increasingly concerned" for April Jones's safety

London (CNN) -- Local residents in Wales joined police Tuesday to search for a five-year-old girl who officers believe was abducted while she played near her home.

Hundreds of people spent the night scouring land around the mid-Wales town of Machynlleth for April Jones, who was last seen getting into a van on Monday evening.

Melanie Biffin, from Machynlleth Council, told CNN that Mayor Gareth Jones and Councillor Mike Williams as well as many other locals "had been up all night on the search."

Dyfed-Powys Police said they are "increasingly concerned" for the girl's safety. Detective Chief Superintendent Simon Powell said police were following several lines of inquiry.

Powell told the Press Association: "April was last seen playing on a bicycle near her home address at around 7.30 p.m. and was seen getting into what we believe was a light-colored van which then drove off.

"We are obviously becoming increasing concerned for her safety and are asking for anyone with information to please contact us."

US: Missing American believed held by Syria regime

James Lawler Duggan / AFP - Getty Images, file

Freelance photographer Austin Tice, seen in this July 2012 picture taken at an undisclosed location, has been missing since Aug. 13.

By Alastair Jamieson, NBC News

The U.S. believes missing American journalist Austin Tice is in the hands of the Syrian government, a State Department spokeswoman said, after a YouTube emerged purporting to show him at the hands of his captors.

Spokeswoman Victoria Nuland told reporters Monday that the State Department was unable to verify the accuracy of the video, which appears to shows Tice with masked men that one expert described as a "caricature of a jihadi group."

Nuland said that the video "may have been staged" and added, "There's a lot of reason for the Syrian Government to duck responsibility, but we continue to believe that, to the best of our knowledge, we think he is in Syrian Government custody." 

The battle for Aleppo: My 18 days with the Syrian rebels

Former U.S. Marine Tice, who worked for outlets including The Washington Post and media group McClatchy Newspapers, has been missing in Syria since Aug. 13.

He posted on Twitter on Aug. 11 saying he had been celebrating his birthday with Syrian rebels.

McClatchy reported on its website Monday that Tice was "alive and in the custody of armed men" and quoted Tice's parents, Marc and Debra, as saying the video was "reassuring."

It quoted a statement from the Houston couple saying:

"Though it is difficult to see our son in such a setting and situation as that depicted in the video, it is reassuring that he appears to be unharmed. It is evident that the current events in Syria are challenging and difficult for everyone involved. Our wish is that peace and stability can once again return to the people of Syria and that our eldest son, Austin, will soon be safely returned to our family."

The video clip, which shows masked men carrying guns, came to light after it was shared on a Facebook page associated with supporters of the government of Syrian President Bashar Assad.

Dad hopes Ex-Marine in Syria will turn up safe

NBC News could not confirm the authenticity of the video. The New York Times reported that several analysts expressed doubts about the authenticity of the video.

The Washington Post also quoted Joseph Holliday, of the Washington-based Institute for the Study of War, as saying the video did not ring true and that the "captors" appeared to be wearing Afghan-style clothing rather than those normally associated with Islamists in Syria.

"It's like a caricature of a jihadi group," he told the newspaper. "It looks like someone went to the Internet, watched pictures of Afghan mujaheddin, then copied them. My gut instinct is that regime security guys dressed up like a bunch of wahoos and dragged him around and released the video to scare the U.S. and others about the danger of al-Qaida extremists in Syria. It would fit their narrative perfectly."

More world stories from NBC News:

Follow World News from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook

US: Missing journalist believed held by Syria regime

James Lawler Duggan / AFP - Getty Images, file

Freelance photographer Austin Tice, seen in this July 2012 picture taken at an undisclosed location, has been missing since Aug. 13.

By Alastair Jamieson, NBC News

The U.S. believes missing American journalist Austin Tice is in the hands of the Syrian government, a State Department spokeswoman said, after a YouTube emerged purporting to show him at the hands of his captors.

Spokeswoman Victoria Nuland told reporters Monday that the State Department was unable to verify the accuracy of the video, which appears to shows Tice with masked men that one expert described as a "caricature of a jihadi group."

Nuland said that the video "may have been staged" and added, "There's a lot of reason for the Syrian Government to duck responsibility, but we continue to believe that, to the best of our knowledge, we think he is in Syrian Government custody." 

The battle for Aleppo: My 18 days with the Syrian rebels

Former U.S. Marine Tice, who worked for outlets including The Washington Post and media group McClatchy Newspapers, has been missing in Syria since Aug. 13.

He posted on Twitter on Aug. 11 saying he had been celebrating his birthday with Syrian rebels.

McClatchy reported on its website Monday that Tice was "alive and in the custody of armed men" and quoted Tice's parents, Marc and Debra, as saying the video was "reassuring."

It quoted a statement from the Houston couple saying:

"Though it is difficult to see our son in such a setting and situation as that depicted in the video, it is reassuring that he appears to be unharmed. It is evident that the current events in Syria are challenging and difficult for everyone involved. Our wish is that peace and stability can once again return to the people of Syria and that our eldest son, Austin, will soon be safely returned to our family."

The video clip, which shows masked men carrying guns, came to light after it was shared on a Facebook page associated with supporters of the government of Syrian President Bashar Assad.

Dad hopes Ex-Marine in Syria will turn up safe

NBC News could not confirm the authenticity of the video. The New York Times reported that several analysts expressed doubts about the authenticity of the video.

The Washington Post also quoted Joseph Holliday, of the Washington-based Institute for the Study of War, as saying the video did not ring true and that the "captors" appeared to be wearing Afghan-style clothing rather than those normally associated with Islamists in Syria.

"It's like a caricature of a jihadi group," he told the newspaper. "It looks like someone went to the Internet, watched pictures of Afghan mujaheddin, then copied them. My gut instinct is that regime security guys dressed up like a bunch of wahoos and dragged him around and released the video to scare the U.S. and others about the danger of al-Qaida extremists in Syria. It would fit their narrative perfectly."

More world stories from NBC News:

Follow World News from NBCNews.com on Twitter and Facebook